Credit Card Guide
Follow Us  twitter facebook You Tube Google+
Credit Cards > Credit Card News > Ask Erica > Which is worse: Bad credit or no credit?


Which is worse: Bad credit or no credit?

November 18, 2013
Ask Erica
email print comment

QDear Erica,

If you had two good kids, but one has bad credit and the other one has no credit, which one would you lend money to first? – Megan

ADear Megan,

Between those two choices I'd have to go with the kid who has a secure job and something I can hold on to as collateral.

As you may have heard, a person who doesn't possess any credit history is strikingly similar in the eyes of a creditor to someone who has used but abused credit. Both are risky customers. Here's why:

Before granting a line of credit or a loan, creditors will want to predict how that potential borrower will probably behave. To do so, they analyze that person's credit reports (and the credit scores that are derived from the financial information on them), as they provide data about a person's past credit use.Ask Erica

In the trade line section of the report, creditors will see such information as when accounts were granted, current balances, credit limits and a detailed payment history The creditor can analyze the report and make a proper lending decision, or just rely on the credit score (which takes all that data and turns it into a number). If the report shows responsibility and the score is high, the creditor's risk in lending money to that person goes down.

Yet, without a report and its complementary score, creditors can't make such predictions. A blank credit history, therefore, is no good to them at all. The end result is that the child with “no credit” is too mysterious to be considered a good credit risk.

Regarding the child with damaged credit, naturally that person would also be one that a lender would be hesitant to do business with. Not paying bills on time or letting them go into collections will scare any lender away. Owing too much money also looks bad. It could be an indication that the person mismanages finances or can't afford living expenses. Additionally, a portion of that person's income is already promised to other obligations, making another debt difficult to repay.

Naturally, however, there are other qualifying factors when analyzing someone for a loan. The past is not always an indication of the future. Present and upcoming circumstances matter, too. That's why I said I'd be prone to lending to the child who is earning a steady income and who can provide me with some tangible security. Both of those would boost my confidence level measurably.

A job that the person has kept for a long time is positive because there is some cash flow with which to repay the loan. If there were to be some valuable property I could keep in case of default (such as a bicycle or laptop), that would be even better. I'd feel even safer because, if the person defaulted, I could sell the item and recoup my losses. Card issuers sometimes ask for collateral, too, in the form of a product called a secured credit card – a card made specifically for those with poor or no credit. The cardholder puts down a deposit to secure the credit line. If he or she defaults, the creditor keeps the money.

So there you go. I can't tell you which of your children you should open your wallet to (I presume these are your kids we're talking about!) since I don't know them personally, but if you want to think like a lender, that's how you do it. And quite frankly, it's a sound method. Remove the emotion from the equation and you're left with one cold hard question: Who is more likely to pay as promised?

Got a question for Erica? Send her an email.




How to make the most of a new travel rewards card - Charge what is required to secure the one-time bonus and make payments on time, then you will be on your way to getting your plane tickets...

Debt settlement unlikely until you're behind on payments - That doesn't mean you can't try, but settlements have their downsides...

How hard inquiries hurt your credit score - Applying for a loan or credit card will trigger a hard inquiry, which will ding your score temporarily...



  If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the ‘Post to Facebook’ box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.

Our editorial content is not sponsored by any bank or credit card issuer. The comments posted below are not provided, reviewed or approved by any company mentioned in our editorial content. Additionally, any companies mentioned in the content do not assume responsibility to ensure that all posts and/or questions are answered.

Secure SSL Technology
Secure SSL
Twitter Facebook You Tube Google+
About Us Privacy Policy Editorial Team Terms of Use
Contact Us California Privacy Rights Media Relations Site Map

Close X